How many people can honestly say they’ve shared a meal with their real life hero? I did, by chance, about 8 years ago and I’ll never forget it. No it wasn’t Angelo Gaja, whom I’ve met and I still have a hole in my head from where he stared at me with his laser-beam eyes. It was Ricardo Legorreta, an architect whose work takes my mind to another place-almost like an amazing barolo. I riddled him with questions all afternoon and even at dinner the same evening and he graciously answered them all with humility. He told me that what he designs is great fun and almost a fantasy because most of his projects come with rather unlimited budgets. The work he admires most however, is the work he has done designing affordable housing; work that has clear budget restrictions but is no less important to the owners.
Over the years, it has occurred to me that the wine business must take the same stance. Anyone, myself included, could make a great bottle of $50 wine. Buy and hire the best and, poof, it’s done. But to put a remarkable wine on the shelf for $15 presents a different challenge. Mistakes are harder to cover and marginal fruit gets exposed. Yes, 95% of the wine out there is well under $15 a bottle and 99% of that is just that, wine. Wine that neither inspires much conversation or keeps you from looking for alternatives in the same price range. Most get the job done, some quite well, and then you keep moving, looking for the next bargain out there. It’s part of the fun of wine and we all do it gladly.
I recently tasted several over-achieving Italian wines (red, white, and sparkling) where I felt the winemaker was making a statement and not a budget. Where each winemaker made their wine, poured a glass, and said, ”here is an honest wine, a thoughtful wine, that will stand up to anything in its class regardless of price”. I’m sharing these wines with you not because they will be the best Italian wines you have ever tasted but because they merit your respect, if not attention and may well be the best Italian wines you’ve tasted for under $15.
Le Fraghe Bardolino Classico 2009
Erste e Neue Pinot Blanc 2010
Anna Maria Abbona Dolcetto di Dogliani ”Sori dij But” 2009
Sorelle Branca Prosecco di Valdobiaddene N.V.
Poggio Basso Chianti 2009