Villa Montepaldi

Villa Montepaldi Chianti Classico 2007       84/100
Roasted red apples rule the nose while worked leather notes whisper underneath. Leather and dusty red cherry flavors swarm the palate and the tannins are in no hurry to leave their post on the finish. A grippy scrapper that will need food to help escort the tannins.
Villa Montepaldi Chianti Classico Tagliafume 2007       85/100
The cocoa, red cherry, and rhubarb notes on the nose are quite enticing while on the attack you are promptly greeted by a stingy, tightly wound effort that is shy in revealing the black pepper, leather, and black currant whispers. Nice raw material but the tannins are locking down the fruit that seems quite happy staying behind the scenes.
Villa Montepaldi Chianti Classico Tagliafume 2008       83/100
Red and black cherry aromas are not shy about meeting you on the nose while in the mouth this well balanced and elegant little number wants for more ripeness to the red currant and sottobosco flavors that finish with a highly mineral edge. God raw material but needs more ripeness to attract attention or saddle up to the table.
Share

Villa Mangiacane

Villa Mangiacane Chianti Classico 2008       89/100
Big time dried floral nose gives me classic chianti classico aromas and I’m not disappointed in the mouth. Plenty of black pepper and sottobosco combine with leather, cocoa, and blackberry to give me a classically styled textbook effort. This is what a grilled porterhouse begs to cozy up to at night. Well done!
Villa Mangiacane Chianti Classico 2007       86/100
The aromas are steeped in black tea, thyme, and spearmint while on the attack mint, eucalyptus, and cocoa combine with black pepper to create a massive attack on the palate.
Villa Mangiacane Chianti Classico Riserva 2006       86/100
Cigar tobacco and dried spices make up the nose but it’s already showing signs of tiring on the palate. A bit oaky and rustic, it’s difficult to cozy up to this one right now. Perhaps in time.
Share

Villa Calcinaia

Villa Calcinaia Chianti Classico 2008       89/100
An unresolved nose shows a gang of red and black fruit and nothing is lacking on the palate either. The black pepper and blackberry driven attack in the mouth goes on for minutes and comes in for a soft landing on the finish. A succulent number that will bring out the best in carefully prepared braised meat dishes. Well done!
Villa Calcinaia Chianti Classico 2007       87/100
Ripe red apples and dried flowers light up the nose while in the mouth you get sufficient fruit, driven by blueberry and sour cherry notes, to frame the chewy acids and tannins that battle for position.
Villa Calcinaia Chianti Classico Riserva 2007        90/100
Baking spice aromas coupled with vanilla and mushroom whispers make for a fairly seductive nose but the real action is on the attack where the sweet tannins meld beautifully with the perfectly ripened blackberry fruit that coats the palate. A superbly well crafted wine that will excel with food.
Share

Villa Cafaggio

Villa Cafaggio Chianti Classico 2008       87/100
A rather fruit driven nose, boasting ample aromas of candied apple, dried plum, and raspberry leads to a rather appealing cherry-drop of a wine. There’s balance, red fruit galore, and structure underneath that makes this a complete, simple, spinner that should give restaurants a reason to wake up. Here’s a middle weight contender that can easily be used to start the food-wine conversation that is Italian wine and food.
Villa Cafaggio Chianti Classico 2007       84/100
Juicy and chunky on the nose, there’s a splash of spice on the palate’s attack that doesn’t ease quickly. This is a full-throttle, leather laden effort that will encourage a round of salumi at the table to greet it.
Villa Cafaggio Chianti Classico Riserva 2007       86/100
A ripe nose of baked earth and red apple brings you into a chew-fest, pitting ripe blackberry flavors against succulent tannins. This is a sneaky powerhouse that displays correct winemaking with hidden elegance.
Villa Cafaggio Chianti Classico Riserva 2006       90/100
Wild herb, cola, and dark fruit moves the nose, but there’s an unstoppable attack on the palate that gives you dark fruits cloaked in succulent acids that won’t quit. Excellent.
Share

Vignamaggio

Vignamaggio Chianti Classico 2007       84/100
Layers of fruit jump-start the nose, complete with red apple, blueberry, and sottobosco. A spicy palate delivers a balanced attack. A correct effort if unexciting.
Vignamaggio Chianti Classico Terre di Prenzano 2007       86/100
An elegant wine that couples spice with power to bring you a deceptively heady wine that commands respect from start to finish. A warm and generous wine that will cozy to food quicker than most in its class given its strong spine and obvious acid. Solid effort
Share